Analysis
England’s university regulator says AI makes coursework assessment close to impossible and urges far greater use of AI-free assessment such as closed-book exams, vivas and controlled presentations
The Office for Students and Advance HE say AI weakens coursework assessment in England and urge more AI-free exams, vivas and controlled presentations.
The Office for Students (OfS), England’s higher education regulator, said on November 11 that universities should use far more AI-free assessment, after research with Advance HE found many assessments are unsupervised and open to AI use. The Guardian’s headline says AI has made it “close to impossible” to assess coursework; that phrase is the Guardian’s, reflecting lecturers’ complaints, not a formal OfS finding.
The essentials
- Findings: the joint report, “Making AI work for students”, found “a significant proportion” of assessments are unsupervised and non-controlled, so students can use AI, sometimes finishing work in minutes, per CARE. It says detection tools do not consistently and reliably identify AI use.
- Risk: the OfS says this poses a “significant risk” to the credibility of degrees from English universities, per CARE. The report does not give a percentage of affected assessments.
- Recommendations: closed-book exams, vivas, controlled presentations, process-based assessment and tasks where students critique AI output, per Superpower Daily. Josh Fleming, the OfS’s director of strategy and delivery, called for “far greater use of AI-free assessment”.
- Sanctions: Superpower Daily says universities could face sanctions under existing standards if assessments fail to show what students know. CARE does not mention sanctions, so we treat this as a single-source claim.
Not a ban on AI
Superpower Daily says the report does not reject AI in assessment. It says assessment designs must still show what students can do and remain accessible.
How solid is the evidence
The research ran from June to September 2026 and drew on conversations with more than 300 students and staff at over 120 institutions. It is qualitative evidence, not a representative survey, so it cannot say how widespread the problem is.
What is not established
- Share of assessments affected: not quantified.
- Formal sanctions or deadlines: single-source, not confirmed.
- Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland: the regulator covers England only.
- The OfS report, the Guardian, FT, Times Higher Education and Reuters pieces: not read directly.
Summary table
| Point | What is stated as of November 7, 2026 | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Regulator | Office for Students, with Advance HE | Superpower Daily |
| Evidence base | Conversations with 300+ students and staff at 120+ institutions | Superpower Daily |
| Core finding | Unsupervised assessments let students use AI undetected | CARE |
| Headline | Guardian: AI makes coursework assessment “close to impossible” | Techmeme (The Guardian) |
| Remedy | Return to traditional exams and in-person presentations | Headtopics |
FAQ
Did the regulator say assessment is impossible?
The “close to impossible” wording is the Guardian’s headline, based on lecturers’ complaints; the OfS itself speaks of a significant risk to degree credibility.
What does it recommend?
Closed-book exams, vivas, controlled presentations, process-based assessment and tasks that critique AI output.
Does it apply outside England?
No. The Office for Students regulates higher education in England.
Method and limits
Checked on November 11, 2026 against Techmeme’s Guardian summary, CARE, Superpower Daily, DesiBlitz and Headtopics. The OfS report was not read directly; the Superpower Daily and CARE pages were fetched.
Sources
- Techmeme (The Guardian): England's university regulator says AI makes grading coursework close to impossible and recommends AI-free assessment (verified 2026-11-08)
- CARE: University assessments completed in minutes using AI (verified 2026-11-08)
- Superpower Daily: England’s university regulator warns AI-weakened assessment could bring sanctions (verified 2026-11-08)
- DesiBlitz: University Students passing Assignments in Minutes with AI (verified 2026-11-08)
- Headtopics: UK Regulator Urges Return to Traditional Exams as AI Threatens Coursework Assessment (verified 2026-11-08)
Spotted an error in this article? Report it · Our corrections policy