Security
Italy fines Meta €805 million over Facebook access to Android gallery
The Italian regulator criticizes Facebook on Android for accessing photos without specific consent. Meta disputes the decision and announces an appeal.
The Italian data protection regulator announced on November 14, 2026 a fine of €805 million against Meta Platforms Ireland. It criticizes a Facebook feature on Android for accessing photos and videos in the gallery without specific and informed consent. Meta disputes the decision and announces an appeal. The general authorization given to the app and the specific consent for this feature are at the heart of the disagreement.
Key points
- The feature concerned: Facebook suggested photos and videos from the gallery to post. According to the regulator, it was activated by default without sufficiently clear explanation.
- Scope: the authority mentions about 20 million Android users in Italy. The announced decision does not target all Android phones or all Meta apps.
- Meta's response: the company considers the sanction disproportionate and says that device authorization is necessary; it announces that it will appeal.
- AI: the investigation did not examine any potential training of models with the photos. The regulator reserves examination of a separate cloud feature.
What the regulator criticizes
The feature, available since 2023, could display gallery images while browsing as posting suggestions. The Garante explains that it opened an investigation in July 2025, after a report by a consumer association in Bolzano.
According to the authority, the app requested general authorization to access the gallery for several uses, without explaining clearly enough that the suggestion feature was also concerned. When full access was granted, it could read the entire gallery. The authority states that it cannot verify which information was actually used.
This capability does not prove that all photos were read, transferred to Meta's servers or published. The press release also does not allow the conclusion that Facebook users on iPhone, Instagram or WhatsApp are targeted by this decision.
Measures imposed and Meta's challenge
The Garante invokes Article 122 of the Italian data protection code, concerning access to information stored on a terminal. It asserts that, for this feature, a general authorization did not replace the required specific consent. Meta also challenged the competence of the Italian regulator; the latter rejected this argument.
The authority asks Meta, within 60 days, to request separate consent, to explain the feature and its deactivation and to leave it disabled by default. It also requests information on the steps taken within 30 days and on the measures implemented within 90 days. The press release does not allow the legal starting point of these deadlines to be determined with certainty.
According to Reuters, Meta says that the feature requires an authorization granted on the device and modifiable in the settings. The company strongly disputes the decision and plans an appeal. The announcement of an appeal does not prove that it has already been filed, nor what its outcome will be.
What the decision does not say about AI
The Garante specifies that the proceedings did not concern the potential use of images to train artificial intelligence, a use that Meta denies. It would therefore be misleading to present the fine as proof that the photos were used to train a model. The authority reserves a separate analysis of a cloud feature launched in 2026.
FAQ
Which apps are covered?
The announced decision concerns Facebook on Android in Italy. The press release does not allow the conclusion to be extended to Instagram, WhatsApp, or Facebook on iPhone.
Did Meta use the photos to train an AI?
The proceedings did not concern this use, which Meta denies. They therefore prove neither that it took place nor that it did not take place.
Has Meta already appealed?
Meta has announced its intention to appeal. The actual filing of the appeal and its outcome are not established here.
Method and limitations
Article based on the Garante's press release and on Meta's reaction reported by Reuters, consulted on November 15, 2026. The full text of the decision was not found in the sources consulted; November 14 is the date of the press release, not necessarily that of the adoption of the act. This is not legal advice.
Sources
- Italian Garante: sanction against Meta and measures ordered, November 14, 2026
- Reuters: Meta's reaction and announcement of an appeal, November 14, 2026
- Bolzano consumer centre: report, September-October 2025 bulletin
Spotted an error in this article? Report it · Our corrections policy