Security
Meta, Apple, Alphabet and Signal keep pressing against Canada’s Bill C-22, which would require metadata retention and access for police; the bill is now before the Senate
Tech firms oppose Canada’s Bill C-22 on lawful access. The House has passed it, with changes, and the Senate is next.
Meta, Apple, Google and Signal are among the companies pushing against Canada’s Bill C-22, the Lawful Access Act. The pressure is not new: Meta, Apple and Google testified to MPs in May and June, and Signal said it could leave Canada rather than comply. The House of Commons passed the bill on June 18, 2026 after committee changes, and it has since moved to the Senate. The bill covers metadata and capability requirements for service providers. Reports say the content of end-to-end encrypted messages cannot be compelled under it, though critics fear its capability orders could weaken encryption.
The essentials
- The bill: C-22, the Lawful Access Act, introduced in March 2026. Part 2 enacts the Supporting Authorized Access to Information Act, which requires electronic service providers to help with lawful access requests.
- Opposition: Meta, Apple, Google and Signal, along with NordVPN, Proton, Windscribe, DuckDuckGo, the Canadian Chamber of Commerce and two US House committees, have raised concerns. Signal said it would leave rather than comply.
- Changes: after committee amendments in June, reports say the metadata retention period was cut to six months, and the bill’s scope and safeguards were adjusted. Google said the changes did not address its core concerns.
- Status: the House passed the bill on June 18, 2026. It is now in the Senate, where campaigners are urging senators to reform it.
Metadata is not message content
Metadata describes a communication, such as who, when and from where, not what was said. Reports say content of end-to-end encrypted messages cannot be compelled under the bill. The companies’ worry is different: capability orders that could force them to build ways in that weaken encryption for everyone.
A new push, or the same one?
The request describes the companies as pressing against the bill now. We found their opposition dated May and June, and a campaign aimed at the Senate. We found no new company statement in November.
What is not established
- Any new statement from Meta, Apple, Alphabet or Signal in November: not found.
- The final text and its retention period: reported as six months; we did not read the amended bill.
- The Senate schedule and likely amendments: not stated.
- Whether Signal would actually leave Canada: a stated threat, not a decision.
- The exact wording on handing metadata to police: ‘retain and hand over’ is a simplification; we did not verify the mechanism clause by clause.
Summary table
| Point | What is stated as of November 7, 2026 | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Bill | C-22, Lawful Access Act, introduced March 2026 | Michael Geist |
| House third reading | June 18, 2026 | ABlawg |
| Reported retention period | Six months after committee changes (originally longer) | The Logic |
| Opponents | Meta, Apple, Google, Signal, NordVPN, Proton and others | OpenMedia |
| Current stage | Senate | OpenMedia |
FAQ
Does Bill C-22 let police read encrypted messages?
Reports say the content of end-to-end encrypted messages cannot be compelled. Critics fear capability orders could weaken encryption in other ways.
Where is the bill now?
The House of Commons passed it on June 18, 2026. It is now before the Senate.
Will Signal leave Canada?
Signal said it would rather leave than comply. That is a stated position, not an announced exit.
Method and limits
Checked on November 16, 2026. We read Michael Geist, The Logic, OpenMedia and ABlawg through search excerpts and page fetches, not the amended bill text. The request presents the pressure as current; the opposition we found dates from May to June, with a Senate campaign since. ‘Retain and hand over’ metadata is a simplification of the bill’s provisions.
Sources
- Michael Geist: The lawful access two-headed surveillance monster: how Bill C-22 went off the rails (verified 2026-11-08)
- The Logic: Changes to the Liberal government’s lawful access bill haven’t quelled Google’s concerns (verified 2026-11-08)
- OpenMedia: Tell the Senate: reform surveillance Bill C-22 (verified 2026-11-08)
- ABlawg: Decrypting Bill C-22, Part I (verified 2026-11-08)
Spotted an error in this article? Report it · Our corrections policy